Her Highness, Charlie Bradbury, the Queen of Moons, quickly became one of the most beloved characters in Supernatural’s epic run, but the show wasted her potential and outraged fans everywhere.

Charlie Bradbury deserved so much better on Supernatural. A beloved queer character, Charlie fell victim to the show’s tendency to kill off fan favourites—but the pattern was painfully clear: female and queer characters were hit the hardest, which showed clear lopsided decision-making and a frustrating curse of Supernatural’s storytelling.